US holds a political power that cannot be questioned, given its unipolar position in state affairs, a superpower with great responsibility. How can one state refuse its demands and charisma.
During the Cold War, US foreign policy was focused on keeping the democratic states intact and free of aggression from the European bloc - the Communist states led by USSR. Now that USSR disintegrated, US knew it could not back away from the scene after becoming the leading actor. And that, it had no choice but to maintain the status quo.
The dilemma here is that, US needs to make judicious planning and organization of its networks of alliances to cut short its supposed commitments, on the one hand. But it needs to keep the political power, which comes with a great deal of compromise while maintaining the balance between the costs or the resources available and the benefits or gains, on the other hand.
The superceding event, the attack on WTO on Septemeber 11, posed a new challenge to not just US but the world. The story of power politics became a comedy show, a manhunt. Bush declared war on terrorism (instead of declaring war against another state) and made a list of countries as part of the coalition (without their consent) then US invaded Iraq and Afghanistan to hunt the terrorists.
In the old days, military alliance is often regarded as a means to balance power that aims to guarantee security among the member states via bilateral or multilateral agreement. Now, with the decline of communism, states no longer see a danger or threat. The trend in military alliance has changed. Bilateral and multilateral alliances appear less visible and ad hoc alliances seem more apparent. There are now states from old alliances that began to close its curtains for US, as they oppose its foreign policy.
The writer of the article gave many reasons for the change. First, other states think that the coalition of the willing is only formed when there is a serious threat like aggression by one state to another state. Second, they also think that the threat of terrorism is just an exaggeration. Third, they think that US, wanting to limit its military commitments, tends to pass the bulk of tasks to their allies.
When Iraq tried to annex Kuwait, US and the allies went on to defend Kuwait with solid conviction. But after the WTO attack, when US declared war on Iraq due to terrorism, a few responded with full support. What transpired in between these events? What was the challenge?
Today, skeptics begin to wonder what is behind the formulation of US foreign policy about the war on terrorism. Who is US after, citizens who commit terrorism or terrorist states? If US is after the terrorists, should we hold their country liable for the crime and must therefore suffer the consequences of war? If US is after a terrorist country, what makes US sure that the said country has committed an act of terrorism against US? What are the criteria and is there a legal basis? Also, why would US involve other countries? The attack was only one occurrence and it happened on the US soil, does this imply that terrorism is the new political power changing the balance of power which is similar to saying a terrorist country is pursuing a policy of imperialism? Or, is the war on terrorism another means of showcasing its policy of prestige?
Up until now, the concept of war on terrorism is still vague and lack legal precepts. I believe this is the reason why the supposed allies would prefer short-term commitments with US nowadays through ad hoc coalitions. And this was what the writer was trying to message accross.
